Shotgun Forum banner

Best 20 Gauge Skeet/Sporting O/U

14K views 40 replies 30 participants last post by  scooter123 
#1 ·
I know "best" is very subjective but I thought I would toss this out there for ideas.

I'm looking to add a 20 ga skeet/sporting O/U to the collection. It will mainly be used for skeet. Our club has sub-gauge tournaments (very casual competition) in which I would like to start participating.

I like Beretta so was looking at the 686 SP Sporting model. I don't care for the way Brownings fit so its unlikely I would go that route. Hard to find many 20 gauge sporters out there.

Prefer to keep it in the $2-3k (but could go a little higher for the right gun).

Suggestions?

Thanks!
 
#2 ·
The 600 series Berettas are good but so are the 725 Brownings. See if you can try them both
 
#5 ·
My primary skeet gun is a 20 gauge Browning XS Skeet with factory adjustable comb and Briley 28 & 410 tubes. I like it so much if I every encountered a new old stock version of the same gun, I would probably buy it if the price was close to reasonable.

I guess if I were looking for a new gun in your price range I would lean toward the Beretta Sliver Pigeon just because I prefer it's looks over the 725 or CXS.
 
#6 ·
I own and like 68x guns. But like other posters have said, there are many good choices available. I'd totally forget about the "Sporting" moniker and just go with whatever gun fits and feels best to you. What makes a "Sporting" gun anyway? Breaking the target is the part of the sport that keeps us coming back! Obviously longer barrels, adjustable combs, non -automatic safeties, good weight, etc. are nice Sporting features, but are they always necessary? That said, most 20 ga. O/U with barrels longer than 28 inches are going to be dedicated Sporting guns anyway, for what that's worth.

Lots of guys, (probably including you since you didn't mention it?) much prefer buying new. That's a solid policy of which there is no negative when one obviously chooses to absorb the slightly higher cost over a used gun. Me, I like buying used when I can. But I buy new also.

The $2,000 to $3,000 range is a good spot to be in. Or even less if you decide to consider gently used and shop wisely. I can't imagine you not finding something you really enjoy owning within that budget. Try to test drive as many as you can.

Good luck and good shooting!
 
#7 ·
If you've got a 12ga O/U that you like already, I'd say a set of Briley subgauge tubes. If it's only 20ga skeet, I'd say a set of Briley Sidekick 2.0 tubes. If you don't have a 12ga O/U, and you think you might want to shoot 12ga for something someday, I'd say a 12ga O/U and some Briley subgauge tubes. You should be able to pick up a used Beretta 682 or 686 or Beretta CXS, get the triggers worked on, and get the subgauge tubes for well under $3k. If you're lucky, you might be able to pick up a Perazzi MT6 for around $2500 and a set of just the 20ga Sidekick 2.0s for $300, leaving some cash to get the trigger worked on, if needed.
 
#9 ·
If you have a 12 ga O/U already I'd highly recommend Briley Ultralight tubes, either fitted or companion style.

Much less money than a dedicated 20 ga. O/U and it will allow you to use the same gun that you're already used to, especially if you're looking to shoot skeet. This is the preferred method of shooting subgauges for that game.
 
#10 ·
paracord said:
Lowbar83 said:
I know "best" is very subjective but I thought I would toss this out there for ideas.

I'm looking to add a 20 ga skeet/sporting O/U to the collection. It will mainly be used for skeet. Our club has sub-gauge tournaments (very casual competition) in which I would like to start participating.

I like Beretta so was looking at the 686 SP Sporting model. I don't care for the way Brownings fit so its unlikely I would go that route. Hard to find many 20 gauge sporters out there.

Prefer to keep it in the $2-3k (but could go a little higher for the right gun).

Suggestions?

Thanks!
If you have a 12 ga O/U already I'd highly recommend Briley Ultralight tubes, either fitted or companion style.

Much less money than a dedicated 20 ga. O/U and it will allow you to use the same gun that you're already used to, especially if you're looking to shoot skeet. This is the preferred method of shooting subgauges for that game.
But what is the fun in that? :D

Plus once my wife figures out there is a cheaper option than buying another gun...well let's not even think about that!
 
#11 ·
I had a tubed gun, the tubes were Briley Ultimate Ultralites. I liked the gun without the tubes in it.
With the tubes installed, it swung like a pig, way to barrel heavy.
I really like shooting 28ga, but not with that gun. I sold it and bought a true 28ga, much better feeling swing.
Before spending the $$$ on tubes try a friends tubed gun to see if it will work for you.
Like Beretta vs. Browning, gun vs. tubed gun is subjective...Try before you buy if possible.
 
#12 ·
Dedicated 20 gauge I'd suggest Browning 725 or Caesar Guerini Summit. I've shot both and really like how they performed. Triggers in both guns are very good. One has ported barrels.

Browning 20 gauge sporters and the CXS are a good choice. Triggers are so-so. CXS doesn't have ported barrels, the others do.

Haven't had the chance to handle the new 686 20 gauge sporters. I expect they handle very much like the field models and weigh 8 to 10 ounces more.

Full tubes work. Tube a 12 gauge and only shoot with the tubes seems to very common. You have a choice of butt or barrel heavy, or adding/removing weight to balance.

My experience with sub tubes were 20 gauge to .410 adaptors. Very dirty. Tried them at skeet a couple of times and decided I'd rather have a .410 gun. Have seen shooters with 12 to 20 gauge adaptors on skeet field and thought they performed well, but have see them on SC fields and thought long targets ate them up.
 
#13 ·
ceh383 said:
I had a tubed gun, the tubes were Briley Ultimate Ultralites. I liked the gun without the tubes in it.
With the tubes installed, it swung like a pig, way to barrel heavy.
I really like shooting 28ga, but not with that gun. I sold it and bought a true 28ga, much better feeling swing.
Before spending the $$$ on tubes try a friends tubed gun to see if it will work for you.
Like Beretta vs. Browning, gun vs. tubed gun is subjective...Try before you buy if possible.
This^^^. One can't argue with success, specifically if considering good old fashioned (or should I say good old new fashioned) American skeet.

Personally, I don't like the way tubed guns feel. Neither full length nor Sidekicks. I sold my Sidekicks. They, in particular, are filthy to boot.

I much prefer a whole different gun for sub ***** shooting. If I were a very serious sub ***** competitor, which I'm not, the only way I'd ever use tubes is with a matched weight carrier barrel. For my sub ***** dabbling, a separate little gun makes me happy.

Good luck and let us know what you choose. Above all, have fun with it.
 
#14 ·
They are pretty much out of fashion these days, but I do see three and even four barrel skeet sets available on occasion. You probably won't find any with long barrels and they will likely be fixed skeet choke, but if you don't like tubes, it's an alternative. I own a four barrel set and like it a lot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Z-Freak
#16 ·
I picked up a Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon I 20 gauge field with 30" HP Optima barrels for $1636 since it's the same exact gun as the sporting. The only differences are no mid-bead, slimmer rib and solid barrels. Everything else is the exactly the same. I wasn't going to pay $300 more for the sporting version since there was no benefit to me for the price difference.
 
#17 ·
+1 if you have a 12ga you already like then TRY someone's tubes if you can (either full length or sidekicks) but only to see if you like the feel of the added weight in your gun.

I recently picked up a CZ Redhead Premier Target 20ga in 30" monte carlo stock and quite happy for it.
 
#18 ·
I have a 686 20gauge Sporting with 30" barrels and an adjustable comb. I also have a set of 28-gauge 30" barrels for it. Really like it - both sets of barrels weigh in at 7 lbs + 1 or 2 oz. Due to the relatively light weight I shoot it best with the gun just out of my shoulder to keep from stopping my swing.

Lettman, I'm pretty sure the Field version is at least 1/2-lb lighter.
 
#19 ·
lettman said:
I picked up a Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon I 20 gauge field with 30" HP Optima barrels for $1636 since it's the same exact gun as the sporting. The only differences are no mid-bead, slimmer rib and solid barrels. Everything else is the exactly the same. I wasn't going to pay $300 more for the sporting version since there was no benefit to me for the price difference.
The stock on the 20 ga. 686 SP1 sporting is quite different and has a thicker, higher comb and a nice right hand palm swell.
 
#20 ·
Vette Jockey2 said:
If I was looking for a 20 gauge O/U, I'd look no further than Guns Unlimited and get one of the Citori Special Sporting Clays Edition. You can pay more for a 20 gauge, but why would you?
I will second this. Good price. I bought the 20 and 28 version and have the .410 on lay a way.Guns Unlimited may be the largest Browning dealer in the U.S.
 
#21 ·
Perdiz said:
I have a 686 20gauge Sporting with 30" barrels and an adjustable comb. I also have a set of 28-gauge 30" barrels for it. Really like it - both sets of barrels weigh in at 7 lbs + 1 or 2 oz. Due to the relatively light weight I shoot it best with the gun just out of my shoulder to keep from stopping my swing.

Lettman, I'm pretty sure the Field version is at least 1/2-lb lighter.
Below are the specifications for the field version and the sporting version for both shotguns. I do not see any difference in weight, comb, heel etc. Also, I have the sporting version of this shotgun in 12 gauge and there in no right hand palm swell. I keep hearing about palm swell on the Silver Pigeon I and I have yet to see it. I had a Browning 525 that had palm swell and the Beretta does not have it.

Specifications

Action:Break
Gauge:20ga
Max Shell Length:3"
Weight:approx. 6.8lbs
Barrel Length:30"
Trigger:Single Selective
Choke:Optima Choke-HP
Type of Sights:Metal Bead
Stock:Oiled Select Checked Walnut w/ floral engraving of grapes on the vine
Caliber or Gauge:20ga
HandednessRight Hand
Drop at Heel:2.26"
Drop at Comb:1.43"
Product TypeShotguns
Item ConditionNew
UPC082442915074
MPNJ686FK0

Specifications

Action:Break
Gauge:20ga
Max Shell Length:3"
Weight:6.8lbs
Barrel Length:30"
Trigger:Single Selective
Choke:Optima Choke-HP
Type of Sights:Metal Bead
Stock:Oiled Select Checked Walnut w/ floral engraving of grapes on the vine
Caliber or Gauge:20ga
HandednessRight Hand
Drop at Heel:2.26"
Drop at Comb:1.43"
Product TypeShotguns
Item ConditionNew
UPC082442915241
MPNJ686SK0
 
#34 ·
Beretta is infamous for providing incorrect information on their website for shotgun specifications. The sporters are indeed a bit heavier and feel more substantial. I’ve owned several field and sporter versions as have several friends.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Schnurb
#25 ·
lettman said:
birdhunter39 said:
686 sporting and field models are indeed different. Wider rib and palm swell are the obvious differences. My 28ga sporter was 7lbs. The 20ga I have now is around 4oz lighter.
Can you provide the specifications from Beretta where these shotguns are different?
I own both and the grip on the sporter also has a tighter radius. The comb is a bit broader on the sporting also.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
#26 ·
lettman said:
Perdiz said:
I have a 686 20gauge Sporting with 30" barrels and an adjustable comb. I also have a set of 28-gauge 30" barrels for it. Really like it - both sets of barrels weigh in at 7 lbs + 1 or 2 oz. Due to the relatively light weight I shoot it best with the gun just out of my shoulder to keep from stopping my swing.

Lettman, I'm pretty sure the Field version is at least 1/2-lb lighter.
Below are the specifications for the field version and the sporting version for both shotguns. I do not see any difference in weight, comb, heel etc. Also, I have the sporting version of this shotgun in 12 gauge and there in no right hand palm swell. I keep hearing about palm swell on the Silver Pigeon I and I have yet to see it. I had a Browning 525 that had palm swell and the Beretta does not have it.

Specifications

Action:Break
Gauge:20ga
Max Shell Length:3"
Weight:approx. 6.8lbs
Barrel Length:30"
Trigger:Single Selective
Choke:Optima Choke-HP
Type of Sights:Metal Bead
Stock:Oiled Select Checked Walnut w/ floral engraving of grapes on the vine
Caliber or Gauge:20ga
HandednessRight Hand
Drop at Heel:2.26"
Drop at Comb:1.43"
Product TypeShotguns
Item ConditionNew
UPC082442915074
MPNJ686FK0

Specifications

Action:Break
Gauge:20ga
Max Shell Length:3"
Weight:6.8lbs
Barrel Length:30"
Trigger:Single Selective
Choke:Optima Choke-HP
Type of Sights:Metal Bead
Stock:Oiled Select Checked Walnut w/ floral engraving of grapes on the vine
Caliber or Gauge:20ga
HandednessRight Hand
Drop at Heel:2.26"
Drop at Comb:1.43"
Product TypeShotguns
Item ConditionNew
UPC082442915241
MPNJ686SK0
The characteristics are essentially the same, although there may be a slightly different shape, which determines the differences in usability. Although here you'll get your hands on it.
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top