Shotgun Forum banner
81 - 93 of 93 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
1,472 Posts
Discussion Starter · #81 ·
I just keep reading "help me" posts all over this forum from shooters of discarding sabots and rifled barrels.
Why?

Is the smooth bore and fosters as accurate as the rifled barrel and sabots?
Maybe.
Sometimes.
Depends.
From the complaints and plea for help, the descriptions such as " my rifled s.g. is all over the place " I'd say maybe some tuned smoothbores outshoot many ailing rifled barrels with expensive ammo.
JC. You seem to be getting pretty fair accuracy from your Savage bolt gun and what you call 9 buck a box ammo.
I already mentioned that SST ammo is 12 bucks and more around these parts.
I can clearly demonstrate groups of UNDER 2" at 50 yards, UNDER 3" at 75 yards from downright CHEAP K.O. ammo and a well tuned downright CHEAP M-500 pump.
A 2 M.O.A. smoothie?
That is a rare beast indeed. I had one that would toss Winchester fosters into 2" at 100 but that was years, and years, ago a very, very, well tuned 870, pinned barrel etc., and ammo from the same lot #.
I doubt, seriously doubt, a smoothie can consistantly shoot 2 MOA.
No one ever said they could.
But from what I'm reading here from the VAST majority of posters is that the rifled guns they are shooting with expensive ammo are NOT shooting anywhere near 2" at 50 and 3" at 100.
A tunned smoothie will and with cheap ammo.
THAT is the crux of my argument.
You seem to want to argue for the sake of it.
I accept argument in the scientific sense only.
I was hoping some other members here would be showing me 2 MOA groups with some rifled pump or auto loader and be specific about the brand of ammo.
By the way.
The cheapest 'sabot" ammo I can find anywhere on the net is Hastings which is a nondiscarding sabot at 8.99 to 9.99 per 5.
I can find NO SST ammo under about 13 bucks a fiver.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
3,417 Posts
jeager106 said:
I can find NO SST ammo under about 13 bucks a fiver.
$8.98....

That is funny....

I last purchased them here....(they are now on back order as of a few weeks ago..)

$8.98....

I regularly purchase them here in bulk...buying 10 boxes at a time and recieving free shipping....9.49 or 9.99 once again depending on membership. (I am a member and my cost per box including the membership is equal to price advertised. Plus you end out getting free shipping regularly)

http://www.sportsmansguide.com/net/cb/cb.aspx?a=294742

http://www.midsouthshooterssupply.com/i ... search=yes

Here they are once agian for $9.53, or $10.05 (depending on whether you are club member)

http://www.cheaperthandirt.com/15474-14752-2492.html

...So Jeager,

As you can see...this is not "what I call 9$"...it is 9$...ammo...

In fact if you want to stretch it...you could even call it 8$ ammo...

JC
 

· Registered
Joined
·
3,417 Posts
jeager106 said:
I just keep reading "help me" posts all over this forum from shooters of discarding sabots and rifled barrels.
Why?
Very simple....Because the majority of the folks that post on this forum shoot rifled guns...and discarding sabots...and this is the worlds largest source for help and information on both... :roll:

JC
 

· Registered
Joined
·
89 Posts
JC, why do you waste your time with this guy?? I seriously doubt that a rifled slug gun owner, who currently spends big money on sabots, would continue to spend big bucks if there wasn't a dramatic improvement in accuracy. The market demand for rifled guns and sabots kinda sums up the whole debate in favor of sabots.

JC, if you get a chance, check out the thread on Lightfields vs Hastings on deer.

John
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,472 Posts
Discussion Starter · #88 ·
JC:
Thanks for the links! :D
Those prices are simply awesome.
In what firearm do you use the SST?
What kind of accuracy to you get at 100 and 150 yards?
I'll spend 9 bucks a five pack for ammo that performs from either my 870 cantilever 12 bore or my Ultra slugger.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,472 Posts
Discussion Starter · #89 ·
J.Mol. said:
JC, why do you waste your time with this guy??
John
John.
The idea behind these gun sites is to share our experience with other members.
If you don't like the content of my posts that's fine.
I've made many statements that nothing I post is a personal attack on anyone or anyone's equpment.
I've read a lot of posts on this site and a huge percentage are from rifled slug shooters getting terrible accuracy from discarding sabots.
I do read a LOT of posts where non discarding sabots are turning in good results from rifled tubes.
My tongue in cheek post was in response to a person that claimed the smooth bore was good only for clubing animals.
The vast majority of s.g./slug hunters still use the foster and smoothie and with darned good results.
I'm still searching for the rifled barrel/discarding sabot that will shoot at least 2" at 100 yards.
I've tried the SST, 385 offerings from both Winchester and Remington, 400 grain Winchester, Brenneke sabot, Remington Copper Solids, Federals offereings and more.
Still no 2" FIVE SHOT groups at 100 yards. :? :?
So, John, what can you offer to help a fellow member in his quest for an accurate discarding sabot bullet?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
209 Posts
Without coming off as too cheaky, have you considered buying a different gun?!?! I would suggest an Ithaca DSII or DSIII, hard to find but deadly accurate in a pump gun. As far as bolt actions I would recommend the Tar Hunt, nicest gun I have ever owned, or a Savage 210F, nearly as accurate but a little rougher around the edges. The Ultra Slug Hunter is also deadly accurate and realtively inexpensive. All thes should easily hit your 2 in. @ 100 criteria, n pun intended.

Scott
 

· Registered
Joined
·
3,417 Posts
Rangeball said:
I don't know cause I haven't been following this saga, but in another thread Jeager mentioned a 1-5 variable scope. Perhaps you simply need more power at the extended ranges to shrink your groups?
I agree 100%...I know that the 2-7x on my Savage results in larger groups than I would be recieivng if I were shooting the 3.5-10 that is on my Tar-Hunt. For me personally, I know my groups would open up at least 2" more than the gun is capable if I were trying to shoot at 125yds with a 5x scope.

JC
 
81 - 93 of 93 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top