Mossberg

 

Currently none of those mentioned makes a pump gun that I would let sleep in my gun safe. Take the same money and buy a nice used M-12 or a M-31.

 

Ithaca for sure

 

870 no contest

 

i dont think winchester "makes" a pumpgun anymore.

 

Remington 870. . . . no contest.

 

Any of them will do the job in competent hands. The key is the operator, or as some have termed it the software.

A better question would be which do you prefer and why.

...

 

870 Wingmaster. An old one with a good price.

 

Remington for sure.

 

Mossberg

Remington 870 Wingmaster

 

I voted Winchester Model 12.

I am new to the boards.

Great information in this Forum.

 

:!: Remington Pump Shotguns = Double Action Bars :!:

 

For this poll I went with the Remington 870 as it is still being made.It is far ahead of any of the Winchesters now in production.If the Winchester Model 12 was still in production I would have gone with Winchester.

 

Remington 870

 

Best gun for the money is a Remington. Best gun would be one that is hand made to your individual fit and shooting style.

 

870 is a workhorse.

 

I gotta say Browning. I started with an Auto 5 and shot it exclusively from 1960 until 1977, switched to an SKB SxS then to a Citori. I wouldn't give up the SKB, but the Brownings stand the test of time.

 

They're all pretty good but my vote goes to Remington.

 

Browning A-5 hands down

 

So, you folks go back TWO years to dig up an old poll.....and then vote for a self-loader in a pump question!!! :?:

Way to go brainiac!!!!!!!! :roll:

 

Mossberg 500

 

Remmy 870, then Mossberg 590. I didn't like my Ithaca DeerSlayer and my Winchester 1300 Defender had several feeding issues, from day one, so I got a refund, then bought the 590 which has no issues with anything.

 

Remington 870 is the toughest of the tough! I have a 20ga one with a hundred thousand rounds through it! Their Model 31 before the 870 was a great pump as well.......

 

I was forced to vote other, am wondering how you can possibly leave out the best currently made pumpgun being produced-the excellent Browning bps?

 

this may be an old poll but I just now voted for a real pump winchester. without winchester where would any other guns be? A MODEL 12 shot in 1912 will and does shoot today just as good as it did back then! and still lock up good and tight and not sloppy like other new guns made at a later date.