Unless you are just looking for an Ithaca, I think that price is a bit high for the condition of the gun. For just a little more, you could get a brand new Mossberg or Rem Express. If you really want that gun, I'd offer the seller about $140 to $150, and if he refuses your offer, I'd look elsewhere. That's just MY opinion. Do whatever you want. In the grand scheme of things, $50 isn't that much to argue about. 8)