Shotgun Forum banner

My Winchester SXP Review

1 reading
70K views 52 replies 19 participants last post by  Jaspo01  
No pump is going to soften or reduce recoil. For goodness sakes, it's is effectively a fixed breech gun until after the shot is fired.

Currently my oldest pumps are from 1948. Not a single one of them has ANY hammer peening like what's in that picture. I would be worried if that was my gun.
 
I have no idea how many shells through my 1948 model 37. I've owned it for a year or so. I know that it's all original and well used before I got it.

I've shot old guns all my life Remingtons, Ithacas, Mossbergs, etc.... Never have I seen a hammer peened like that. But hey, if ya like pot metal, go for it.

For my entire stable of Ithaca 37's from 1948-1952 I've spent a grand total of $22 after cleaning them up, often for the first time since new.

Stick around a while and perhaps you'll learn a thing or two. Learn what and how to buy, stay away from the bottom of the quality barrel, and you'll avoid the money pits. Junk was junk when new.
 
Virginian, just think how much better off you and I would be if we dumped all these old money pits and bought new and improved guns!

You go first, I'll follow, lol!
 
Who said anything about blueing? I thought we were talking about a peened over soft hammer. You said basket case, which here means doesn't work, needs fixing, etc.. Now you want to talk about total restoration.

How many old 870's have you bought? Ithaca 37's? Remington 1100's? Pray tell, enlighten us as to all the worn out, quality to begin with, shotguns you see on the dealer's shelf?

If you want new plastic, pot metal, aluminum that's fine. Just don't use the excuse that older guns are basket cases. Your argument doesn't hold water.