Shotgun Forum banner

Whats a Shotgun you own that was better than you expected?

17364 Views 206 Replies 153 Participants Last post by  Bahama Joe
What was a shotgun that you've owned that was better than expectations?
Mine has been a Charles Daly 20ga auto(the older 600 version).. Ive owned it for 19 years and its had more than a few thousand rounds through it. My wife bought it for me to bust brush and bad weather with.. Very plain black synthetic, cherekoted(or something like it) barrel,and its been rock solid all these years.. Its been crazy reliable with all loads in all kinds of weather..
Have you had a shotgun that exceeded expectations or reputation?
  • Like
Reactions: 3
81 - 100 of 207 Posts
Savage 410 pump plain barrel performs all well for me as any. After a hundred guns I have owned over 70 shooting years I decided I needed a truck gun. Length of pull an inch shorter than any of my others. 175 bucks.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
Mossberg SA-28, fit and finish was much better that expected. Only problem I had was when it got very dusty while hunting in western Kansas and it started jamming. I’ve put about 300 flawless rounds through it shooting 5 stand and trap.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
A lot of “surprising” Turkish guns.;)
  • Like
Reactions: 4
that viper 28ga is my next purchse..
Those Tristar's sure seem to get a lot of praise.
  • Like
Reactions: 4
Hard to say with so many different one's, they all amaze me but I'd have to say I'm surprised with the Franchi Luigi 20 gauge the most...However I'm of the same thinking of KYLongrifle and the viper 28 gauge for my next purchase, just waiting to hear how he likes his first.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
that viper 28ga is my next purchse..
That tristar G2 viper 28ga. I couldn't be any happier. Its bad medicine on squirrels and crows. I bought a new mossberg SA 20ga turkey gun. Back before turkey season. I want another 28ga. It will be another tristar or mossberg 28ga.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
My 1100 so far. It is also my first semi auto shotgun.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Man, I can tell you that door swings both ways on names and reps.
Charles Daly was an importer offering the high end and the low end, and everything in between. Some Charels Daly guns you can't give away but some you can't even afford to buy either. Most likely your gun could be a Savage, Remington or Browning trade gun, look up your model number in the book and see who the maker was.
I had at least two guns I wish I would have never sold: a Beretta Mark II with 32" barrel, and a Browning Auto-5 / 12 gauge R, [recoil barrel into the receiver] first model with choke tubes and a barrel rib. Loved it.

But then came the Winchester 101 Water Foul Special with 32" barrels and screw in Win-chokes in 1998. I could not even hit a trap target or even a skeet target let alone hunt ducks. But I found out what was wrong, [interesting Delima]. I could not hit a pattern board at 40 yards, the top barrel shot way high and to the left, the bottom barrel shot way low and to the right. So I tried to call Winchester at Olin and they told me the gun was too old out of manufacture date and could not take responsibility for it.
[Very interesting], so I called Lefever in New York, who still works on shotguns and talked to a rep. After I explained everything over the phone, he told me I had three choices, [1] cut the barrels off 2&1/2" and only shoot skeet. [2] send the gun to Lefever and they would take the barrels apart, unsolder everything, strip the barrels, realign the barrels, re-solder the barrels and hot blue everything for $1000.00 bucks. I only paid $600.00 when I bought it. [3] Sell the gun to somebody that I really disliked, and that's what I did, I sold it to an arrogant *** that nobody liked for $600.00 bucks. He probably still goes to an eye doctor every 6 months trying to figure out why he can't hit anything with that gun. LOL Mike
I laughed out loud. Thanks for the chuckle.
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: 5
Weatherby Element 12 gauge inertia action. Light and reliable good pheasant hunting gun.
What was a shotgun that you've owned that was better than expectations?
Mine has been a Charles Daly 20ga auto(the older 600 version).. Ive owned it for 19 years and its had more than a few thousand rounds through it. My wife bought it for me to bust brush and bad weather with.. Very plain black synthetic, cherekoted(or something like it) barrel,and its been rock solid all these years.. Its been crazy reliable with all loads in all kinds of weather..
Have you had a shotgun that exceeded expectations or reputation?
Yes I have, two 12 gauges that do actually.
1) My Remington 1100 was 45 years old before I ever replaced the o rings. Upon removal I learned that they were still fine!
2) My Savage Renegauge is the best shooting & lightest recoiling shotgun I've ever shot. After thousands of rounds I can see no wear at all & it seems to stay remarkably clean. Just my biased, unprofessional opinion.
  • Like
Reactions: 3
My 12ga Ithaca 37 Featherlight that I bought new in 1969. I knew it was supposed to be a good shotgun, but had no idea it would still be going strong 53 years later.
  • Like
Reactions: 3
lossking,
A quality gun will be doing it's job over a longevity of time, without repairs. Your old 12 gauge Ithaca Featherlight purchased in 1969 is one of those quality guns. A quality gun will last more than a few life times, with out repairs.

all the best,

Pine Creek/Dave
L.C. Smith Man

I have quality L.C. Smith double guns that are over 100 years old and work like brand spanking new, look that way also.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 4
Hands down, Japanese SKB 685 in 12 gauge with 30" bbls...1993 vintage. Rock solid lockup with Greener-style lock-up, Beretta 680-type ears mating to receiver, replaceable trunnions, leaf-type hammer springs a la DT10 (& others), consistent 2-3 lb crisp triggers, well-regulated barrels, very decent, well-finished wood, overall excellent fit & finish. An excellent shotgun at any price...at today's prices for a nice example, an absolute steal!

Wood Wood stain Everyday carry Blade Tints and shades
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 2
Pointer Phenoma 410. Have run just over 1K of factory and reloaded 2 1/2“ target loads with only 1 FTF. The FTF was on one of my reloads that I noticed was not crimped properly when I put it in the magazine. Love this gun! Has surpassed all my expectations so far.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Man, I can tell you that door swings both ways on names and reps.
Charles Daly was an importer offering the high end and the low end, and everything in between. Some Charels Daly guns you can't give away but some you can't even afford to buy either. Most likely your gun could be a Savage, Remington or Browning trade gun, look up your model number in the book and see who the maker was.
I had at least two guns I wish I would have never sold: a Beretta Mark II with 32" barrel, and a Browning Auto-5 / 12 gauge R, [recoil barrel into the receiver] first model with choke tubes and a barrel rib. Loved it.

But then came the Winchester 101 Water Foul Special with 32" barrels and screw in Win-chokes in 1998. I could not even hit a trap target or even a skeet target let alone hunt ducks. But I found out what was wrong, [interesting Delima]. I could not hit a pattern board at 40 yards, the top barrel shot way high and to the left, the bottom barrel shot way low and to the right. So I tried to call Winchester at Olin and they told me the gun was too old out of manufacture date and could not take responsibility for it.
[Very interesting], so I called Lefever in New York, who still works on shotguns and talked to a rep. After I explained everything over the phone, he told me I had three choices, [1] cut the barrels off 2&1/2" and only shoot skeet. [2] send the gun to Lefever and they would take the barrels apart, unsolder everything, strip the barrels, realign the barrels, re-solder the barrels and hot blue everything for $1000.00 bucks. I only paid $600.00 when I bought it. [3] Sell the gun to somebody that I really disliked, and that's what I did, I sold it to an arrogant *** that nobody liked for $600.00 bucks. He probably still goes to an eye doctor every 6 months trying to figure out why he can't hit anything with that gun. LOL Mike
PS: I own an SKB model #385, 20 gauge with 28" barrels, 6 choke tubes, in an SKB case. Gotta be the best upland bird gun I ever pull up and pretty as a picture too, a real head turner.
Mike
  • Like
Reactions: 1
My 1976 Browning A-5 20-gauge magnum, it never has let me down.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
In 1974 I acquired a 20ga. Fox/Savage SxS. I got it as 'Boot' in a gun trade. Nice little SXS at the time I was on Model 12 Winchesters only. I took it to the stock tanks in West Texas during dove season that year. If a dove flew within 35yds. of that muzzle it died. My average went from 6-8 shells per bird on the ground, including several doubles, to no misses inside the 35yd. range. Awesome little shotgun. I gave it to my best friend's wife so she could go dove hunting with us. IF she ever missed a bird while shooting that gun, I never saw it happen. I have been sold on 20ga. and 28ga. bird guns since, all SxS or O/U doubles. Gave all the Model 12's to my sons. They need the exercise more than I do.;)
Roy
  • Like
Reactions: 2
My Remington 3200 skeet I purchased from the Rod & Gun club in Germany while serving in the U.S. Army in 1978-1981. I think I paid $325 for it. It was used by the Army skeet team. I have had 0 problems with it.
I came home from Germany in 1967. Went straight to K-Mart and bought a Marlin golden 39A. Sence then I have bought several shotguns. Some I like and some I didn't. But never had any problem with any of them. My favorite shotgun by far is the Remington 870 Pump. Just bought a Remington 870 410 TSS turkey. Can't wait to head to the range see how good it patterns. It makes three 410 shotguns I have. One being a Mossberg, the other being stevens single shot. All three set up for turkey hunting. Using Truchoke tubes for the best patterns.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
Saiga 12gauge,and a old winchester model97 are my favorites have a couple mossburgs and rebuilding a Sears model200 Ted Williams 20gauge
Marocchi Model 99. I have two of these "poor man's Perazzi" shotguns, one with a 30" and another with a 32" barrel. They were designed with the same action/lock up system as the Perazzi MX-8 and others. I might be the only guy smart enough (or stupid enough) to own two of these shotguns. Marocchi Arma did a horrible job of marketing these sporting clays O/U's when they brought them to the U.S. They were selling like hotcakes in Europe, including Great Britain. They were competing with Caesar Guerini for a market share. Guerini was taking out full page, beautifully done ads in Sporting Clays Magazine while Marocchi had 2"x3" boring ads in the back few pages. Guess who won. It didn't take long before Marocchi basically bailed out of the U.S. You gotta go glitz with Americans! This is not to disparage Guerini because I think they are fine guns too, but the Marocchi model 99 was a great gun as well. And by the way, I own/shoot a Perazzi MX-8 and I can tell you those Marocchis shoot just right up there with the Perazzi.
That's why they put glitter on bass boats
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: 2
81 - 100 of 207 Posts
Top