I'm an 870 guy.
A 20 gauge Wingmaster was my 14th birthday present, I had it until it got stolen a couple years later. It was replaced with a 12 gauge Wingmaster which I still have. I have a 50's era Wingmaster with a cut down 18" barrel as it came to me. And there's the 50's era Wingmaster TB that was a police gun that wears a 20" barrel with rifle sights. And finally I have my department issue 870 with the 18" barrel. I've got plenty for home defense.
Having said all that, I really want a semi-auto "HD" gun with a short(ish) barrel. I love my 870's so something that is basically the same is what I want. I'm trying to decide which is a better starting point, an 1100 or an 11-87. I want a smooth bore, nothing rifled. I also would prefer it no longer than 20". And I would prefer it not to have the Remington factory rifle sights, although that is a really minor point.
I would like it to function with birdshot I can buy in bulk at wally-world, so practice is a lil cheaper. I do not need it to function with 3" shells. Even with buckshot and slugs I only use 2 3/4".
My thought was an 11-87 with the pressure comp, cut down and if needed enlarge the gas ports so it works with birdshot and the pressure compensation would keep it from being too rough with the buckshot.
BUT....I've had people tell me an 1100 will do that anyway. I'm not sure about the shorter barrels though.
So, I'm seeking advice and suggestions.
A 20 gauge Wingmaster was my 14th birthday present, I had it until it got stolen a couple years later. It was replaced with a 12 gauge Wingmaster which I still have. I have a 50's era Wingmaster with a cut down 18" barrel as it came to me. And there's the 50's era Wingmaster TB that was a police gun that wears a 20" barrel with rifle sights. And finally I have my department issue 870 with the 18" barrel. I've got plenty for home defense.
Having said all that, I really want a semi-auto "HD" gun with a short(ish) barrel. I love my 870's so something that is basically the same is what I want. I'm trying to decide which is a better starting point, an 1100 or an 11-87. I want a smooth bore, nothing rifled. I also would prefer it no longer than 20". And I would prefer it not to have the Remington factory rifle sights, although that is a really minor point.
I would like it to function with birdshot I can buy in bulk at wally-world, so practice is a lil cheaper. I do not need it to function with 3" shells. Even with buckshot and slugs I only use 2 3/4".
My thought was an 11-87 with the pressure comp, cut down and if needed enlarge the gas ports so it works with birdshot and the pressure compensation would keep it from being too rough with the buckshot.
BUT....I've had people tell me an 1100 will do that anyway. I'm not sure about the shorter barrels though.
So, I'm seeking advice and suggestions.