Shotgun Forum banner

Budget doubles

7.3K views 41 replies 26 participants last post by  R10D  
#1 ·
Hello, I'm beginning to explore options for a "new" (to me anyway) double barrel shotgun. I currently only own pumps and gas guns, and need a break action for dog training and hunt tests. I may use this gun for hunting as well, but that isn't necessarily the primary purpose.

What am I looking for?

Reliable
New or used.
Under 1k, preferably closer to 600
26 or 28" barrels.
Single trigger (not a deal breaker)
Removable chokes
OU or SxS
12 or 16ga (if on a 16ga frame)

I would love a straight grip 16ga SxS with removable chokes, but I'm not sure such an animal exists within my budget...

Any suggestions what to look for? What to stay away from?
 
#4 ·
drsfmd said:
Stay away from guns made in Turkey, Brazil, Russia, the Philippines, and older guns made in Spain or Belgium.

You're not likely to find something that meets all of your criteria at that price point.
Interestingly enough, I've heard too many good things about the Turkish Huglu shotguns. I don't think I'd shy from one...

As for the other imports, what brands would they fall under?

What is our there for "true" 16ga guns? I would LOVE to add a 16 to my safe, but if I'm going to get a 16, I want a 16ga (or 20ga) frame and 16ga barrel blanks. I would pay more for a purpose built 16 than a 12. I would not be interested in a 16 that is 12ga weight.

Obviously the ideal world, and real world seldom converge. I am willing to compromise on some things. A double trigger would not be a deal breaker for me, but would take an adjustment. I have fired double trigger guns before, but I am left handed, and have also in the past accidentally fired both barrels as the rear trigger is usually offset to the left and my index finger tends to ride on the edge of it... Follow up shots are quite difficult when you blow both barrels at once. LOL

Fixed chokes would not be a deal breaker, as long as the tight choke was no tighter than mod.

Reliability and budget are first and foremost.
 
#5 ·
Older AyA made for Sears should fit your bill; but go over it with a fine-toothed comb
 
#8 ·
freak007 said:
Interestingly enough, I've heard too many good things about the Turkish Huglu shotguns. I don't think I'd shy from one...
You've heard the echo chamber on their sub-forum. Have you read the dozens of threads in the other forums from upset owners who had their brand new guns fail?

freak007 said:
As for the other imports, what brands would they fall under?
All.of.them. Don't buy any gun made in those countries unless you're prepared to flush away the money.
 
#9 ·
Vette Jockey said:
If fixed chokes are not a deal-breaker, then look at the Japanese-made SKB's. Those, in 12 gauges, will hit every one of your other "wants" .
If the SKB double guns now are the same quality as the basic field Model 500 I bought back in `74 when they were building them for Ithaca, they are absolutely terrific guns. Don`t think you`ll hit your price point, though, unless you can find one used.
 
#10 ·
Tidefanatic said:
If the SKB double guns now are the same quality as the basic field Model 500 I bought back in `74 when they were building them for Ithaca, they are absolutely terrific guns. Don`t think you`ll hit your price point, though, unless you can find one used.
Since I specified "Japanese-made" SKB's and not the Turkish-made versions, they will only be bought used. And how many sub-$1000, fixed choke, Japanese-made SKB's would you like to buy? There are 6 on Gunbroker, right now, for less than $1000.
 
#11 ·
Vette Jockey said:
Tidefanatic said:
If the SKB double guns now are the same quality as the basic field Model 500 I bought back in `74 when they were building them for Ithaca, they are absolutely terrific guns. Don`t think you`ll hit your price point, though, unless you can find one used.
Since I specified "Japanese-made" SKB's and not the Turkish-made versions, they will only be bought used. And how many sub-$1000, fixed choke, Japanese-made SKB's would you like to buy? There are 6 on Gunbroker, right now, for less than $1000.
I most humbly stand corrected. Thought he preferred around 600.
 
#12 ·
I am willing to compromise on some things. A double trigger would not be a deal breaker for me, but would take an adjustment. I have fired double trigger guns before, but I am left handed, and have also in the past accidentally fired both barrels as the rear trigger is usually offset to the left and my index finger tends to ride on the edge of it... Follow up shots are quite difficult when you blow both barrels at once. LOL
I am LH as well; first time firing any gun other than a .22 was a 12 double and I did that as well. Shied away from them (and passed up GREAT deals) for almost 40 years until I got talked into buying the S&W Elite Gold on closeout. Took me all of three shots to remeber to switch triggers.
Personally, I find the RH SxS to be most LH friendly - your finger slides back tot he back trigger without having to maneuver around the trigger or get your knuckle busted like a RH shooter often has happen.

If you find one with tight fixed chokes, they can be easily opened up to something more suitable.

How much actual shooting will you be doing during your training and tests? There are several makers, most likely above $600 but below $1K that will work.
 
#13 ·
#14 ·
drsfmd said:
freak007 said:
Interestingly enough, I've heard too many good things about the Turkish Huglu shotguns. I don't think I'd shy from one...
You've heard the echo chamber on their sub-forum. Have you read the dozens of threads in the other forums from upset owners who had their brand new guns fail?

freak007 said:
As for the other imports, what brands would they fall under?
All.of.them. Don't buy any gun made in those countries unless you're prepared to flush away the money.
Find those "dozens of threads" from this decade.
 
#15 ·
It would be wonderful if there was a good $500 O/U shotgun, a delicious $1 hamburger or a durable $3000 pickup truck. However, it's really hard to grow beef that cheaply, let alone process it, cook it and serve it on a bun and clean plate for a dollar. O/U shotguns are quite complicated to make well and their popularity keeps good ones bringing good money, and cheep ones a gamble. A new 3/4 ton pickup is in the $50,000 to $60,000 range today... But a good $1000 to $1500 shotgun will out last several of those trucks. Use your common sense when looking for a good deal.
 
#16 ·
SxS, for training and hunt tests try an older Stevens, probably a 5100.
They work fine and have passed the test of time. Real gunsmiths can make the occasional needed repairs, parts replacers will call them a wall hanger.
 
#18 ·
I had a similar want, albeit my budget was higher and I almost always buy new so I can put the first handling mark in it!

In any case after a very poor experience with the Dickinson Custom Shop, I bought a Rizzini FAIR 16 gauge Isede.

28" Barrels
Single Trigger
Screw In Chokes
Straight English Grip

Check with John Boyd at Quality Arms in Houston. He may have some used ones.

So far I am happy with mine.

Bob
 
#19 ·
I've got 2 CZ's, made by Huglu. One was defective and was sent back. CZ customer service was incredible and I had a new gun in a week. The other gun, a SxS 20, is a joy to shoot and has had no problems.

So I agree that a Huglu is a gamble, but one I'm willing to take with CZ standing behind it.
 
#21 ·
freak007 said:
What am I looking for?

Reliable
New or used.
Under 1k, preferably closer to 600
26 or 28" barrels.
Single trigger (not a deal breaker)
Removable chokes
OU or SxS
12 or 16ga (if on a 16ga frame)

I would love a straight grip 16ga SxS with removable chokes, but I'm not sure such an animal exists within my budget...
The following comments are primarily concerning side-by-sides . . .

If you get past your removable choke requirement, your search will be MUCH easier. Removable chokes are overrated. Just figure out what you're going to use the gun for 70 percent of the time and have your chokes opened up to be appropriate for that. Heck, IC/MOD would likely cover 90 percent-plus of conceivable needs just fine.

There are lots of good field grade side by sides out there that can be bought for less than $1,000.

BTW, I bet once you start using double triggers on a side-by-side you won't want anything else.
 
#24 ·
Hear me out, I advise STRONGLY against a new double. For the money, you literally can not do better than a Ithaca made Lefever Nitro Special. In my opinion, they are the last true gem in affordable side by sides before things begun to be cheapened. That said, I know more than a few folks who swear on a Savage 311. Those run about half of what you quoted but do not think they are cheap guns. Just inexpensive. If you can get past brand new in the box guns you will likely be rewarded with many more years of trouble free service than with new guns.