dcat said:
OldStufferA5#1911 said:
You should be able to make good hits hip shooting at 20 feet and less, practice.
Sights are for distance and exra-fine accuracy, both of which are of limited use in self defense situations.
I guess that really depends on what your definition of good hits is.
Shooting my HD shotgun with Federal FC, the buckshot is just coming out of the wad at 20 feet so the pattern is about 1-1/2". I am morally and legally responsible to put those pellets where they need to go.
That is quite true, and yet soooooo many people have an extreme "accuracy expectation" for firearms at what cannot be described as anything other than Point Blank distance.
People all over proclaim handgun/ammunition combinations that will not shoot 1" at 25 yards to be "too inaccurate" for self defense use, like they think they are going to have to thread a needle somehow. "The shirt is bullet proof,, but if I can just hit the button-hole, it'll get through there, so I need Button-Hole Selection Ammo".
Your shotgun is not a Sniper Rifle, never will be, no matter what Magic Ammo Federal produces, yet you seem to want it to be and you want to use it like one.
How wide is that target you need to shoot at 20 feet?
I am about 16" wide across my important bodily parts, not including arms.
I am going to call a "good hit" as anything within a 16"W x 24"H Upper Body Area
A Really Good Hit is that 8" Pie Plate just below the neck.
That Guy Who Needs Shot who is 20 feet away from you, charges you, if you are not ALREADY SHOULDERED, it will take him 1.0 second or less to get to you, you do not have time to shoulder. Better hip shoot it, twice, maybe 3 times.
How's your reaction time?
Normal Human Being from decision to action is between 1/4 and 1/2 second, it only gets longer as you age. That 1/4 second belongs to the 20-somethings who are essentially "waiting for the go-signal"
.
If you can't put that 1 1/2" cluster of balls into the upper torso from the hip as he is closing distance on you, you'd better practice.
1/2 second in that 1 1/2" is only .75" at 10 feet.
At 6 feet he can reach your shouldered gun, so you don't really have 20 feet, it's 14.
So, the Guy Who Needs Shot only has to cover 14-15 feet to get a hand to your gun, has 3/4 second to do it, YOU will need 1/2 second to see him charge, decide to shoot him, try to shoulder it so you can insure your "liability" with those buckshot is covered, get 1/2 shouldered when he slams into you, knifes the hell out of you (or perhaps just slams you into a wall or drives you into the floor (concussion?)), maybe then shoots you with your own Flite Control Wad, from 4 feet. Maybe twice.
Ever watch someone try to draw a handgun, from a holster (not a complicated Level III retention holster, just a simple friction-retention leather or Kydex gun-holder)?
The Draw Time vs. the Attacker Distance Covering is why the "21-foot rule" exists.
A non-crippled Human Being can cover that 21 feet before almost anyone can get a gun pulled out of that holster and bring it to bear.
Don't try to bum-rush Jerry Miculic, Doug Koenig, and a host of others, it's suicide, but they are not "typical" people.
Are you going to walk around your house clearing it shouldered?
Ever done that?
It's good for focusing you ahead, but you tend to lose Situational Awareness of the larger picture, your head "comes off the swivel". You become easier to blind-side.
Zimmerman was blind-sided by a larger assailant he did not see coming.
"Oh ****!!!!" allows no time for fine accuracy aiming. You need effective hits on target, and you need them like yesterday.
In theory, theory and reality are the same thing.
In reality, they seldom match up, theory falls short a lot of times.