We've been on the fence about which shotgun to get for my 11year old since he was 10 (it's almost a year from the month he passed his hunters safety on his first try

).
We compared many and came down to a Rem 1100LT, Rem 11-87 youth, CD 20ga, and 870 youth. The 870 was written off after deciding that it was close enough in price to a used 1100 or new CD. As we were getting close to buying the 11-87, Remington gets bought out and the price increased dramatically!!!
So the dilemma of spend more or get another came up. Fortunately we came across this forum and thread so we decided to do some more research into the CD youth semi 20ga...
Today, a year after getting his hunters safety card, we spent a couple of hours at the trap range (mostly him with the range master doing excellent one on one instruction). That grin on his face after busting a few clays was priceless.
After a box of the Winchester ammo, starting with FTE's, the hulls were ejecting about 6 to 12 inches away which was great [after the first few FTE's, my son quipped "hey, why do you need an expensive O/U when this gun does the same with the shells?:roll:"]. I'm saving yellow hulls now just in case I have to dig out the reloader :shock:
Thanks to jds and Bobeau for posting their experiences. You guys are right on target with this shotgun!
jds said:
I'll start by stating this Charles Daly 20ga semi-auto built by Akkar in Turkey came out of the box well oiled and surprisingly clean. ... Here's the 20ga ammunition we used:
[snip]
Winchester Super Target 2-3/4", 7/8oz. 7&1/2-shot (50-rounds)
[snip]
This shotgun fired & cycled every type/brand shell we tried on this list mentioned above 100% every time except for the Winchester Super Target value pack shells at first. [snip]
[\quote] :shock: